The Lord of the Rings Trilogy (shortened to LOTR from here on) is the Holy Bible of fantasy novels. J.R.R. Tolkien did not invent elves, dwarves or trolls, but he was the first to create a detailed world for them, full of history and legend. He treated his land, called Middle-Earth, with a respect and dignity never matched by any author previous, and because of it fans have a unique reverence for the man. As such, turning LOTR into film comes with a lot of pressure; for instance, a screenwriter can get away with making drastic changes to a Michael Crichton novel, but altering LOTR would be sacrilegious.
The other pressure is financial; with several hundred million dollars sunk into back-to-back-to-back production of the three books, any problem with Fellowship of the Ring, the first installment, could spell death for the other two. However, I can confidently say that any worries or concerns the studio may have had are about to disappear, because Fellowship of the Ring is simply incredible. Director Peter Jackson has managed to capture the magic of Tolkien?s world and turn it into a moving drama that will undoubtedly be the next Star Wars. Barring some misstep in The Two Towers or Return of the King, the second and third parts of the trilogy, Peter Jackson?s name will enter the fantasy annals alongside George Lucas and Steven Spielberg as a key player in the genre?s history.
The story is complex and involves over a dozen characters so I will not go into detail about it here. In a nutshell, a hobbit named Frodo (a hobbit looks human but stands about waist-high) has to journey to the evil land of Mordor to destroy a Ring that in the wrong hands could enslave the world. Along the way he picks up companions from the Elf, Dwarf and Human realms, and they fight against all manner of beast, from orcs to trolls to goblins. The first half of the film is spent introducing the various characters to us, explaining Middle-Earth?s pertinent history, and setting up the reasons for Frodo?s journey. The second half of the film begins the quest to Mordor. It is a powerful tale, one Jackson and screenwriters Philippa Bowens and Fran Walsh convert very well to the screen.
Fellowship?s cast includes an impressive number of seasoned actors combined with a host of newer faces. Sir Ian McKellan plays Gandalf, an old wizard who discovers much of the peril facing the world. McKellan is wonderful in the role, giving his character an old man?s mirth combined with a desperate drive to see the side of the Good win. Christopher Lee plays Saruman, the head of Gandalf?s order, with a steely gaze and an air of knowledge befitting an ancient wizard. Hugo Weaving, Cate Blanchett and Liv Tyler play immortal Elves named Elrond, Galadriel and Arwen. The first two do fine with their roles but are not given enough screen time to really get into them, while Tyler struggles a bit with hers. Viggo Mortensen, Sean Bean and Orlando Bloom play Aragorn, Boromir and Legolas, three fighters who help Frodo on his journey. Their characters do not get a chance to really define themselves beyond being fighters, so they wind up being, the good swordsman, the shifty swordsman and the elf who never misses with an arrow. Finally, the various key hobbits, Frodo, Bilbo, Sam, Pippin and Merry are played by Elijah Wood, Ian Holm, Sean Astin, Billy Boyd and Dominic Monaghan respectively, and of them all, it is Wood as Frodo who outdoes the rest. Wood?s face and movements all become so convincing that by the three-hour mark, you truly can forget he is not a three-feet high Hobbit. When compared to the acting in other epic fantasy films, the cast of Fellowship of the Ring is a cut above, despite certain character limitations.
To make LOTR a true success, Peter Jackson had to somehow recreate Tolkien?s Middle-Earth on the screen, a task with which he apparently had no problems. Everything from the cute underground hobbit dwellings to the very evil land of Mordor is perfectly rendered, thanks to cinematographer Andrew Lesnie and production designer Grant Major. The special effects team deserves praise as well for some truly terrifying monsters; their orcs are much more evil and scary than anything I had ever pictured while reading the books, and the CGI is almost never noticeably fake.
Fans of the trilogy will notice some glaring omissions and changes to the first book. No vitally important plot points were lost, while a few items from the second book have been moved to the first film to keep the action and drama flowing. About the only thing that I expect the diehard fans to balk at is the lack of history behind each character. While Frodo and Gandalf, arguably the two most important characters in the film, are given the time to establish their motivations and personalities, the sections from the book where each character explains why he is there and why he is willing to help Frodo on his quest is lost; instead, many of the supporting characters just seem to be there. One character in particular, Liv Tyler?s Arwen, has had her story drastically increased in size compared to the book and her actions don?t quite work. She appears without preamble, takes an intensely important role in protecting Frodo, and then disappears again, all with little in the way of explanation.
For parents wondering if Fellowship of the Ring is alright for their children to see, I say it depends on their age. The film is a bit much for younger children, with fight scenes that rival Braveheart for gore and violence, but like Star Wars, it should become a favourite for older children who can handle the action. Peter Jackson?s film is epic, magic, and moving and is likely the only film of 2001 that I will vividly remember in ten years. I highly recommend it as the film to go see over the Christmas holidays, as it is the beginning of what will be a wonderful, long-to-be-cherished trilogy that expertly tells a story many thought could never be properly adapted to the big screen.
Grade: A
Tim Chandler
