Teenagers today are not like the teenagers of yesterday. So says everyone. Kids today are detached, unemotional, and do not understand responsibility or commitment. So says everyone. The problem is, “everyone” can’t decide on what to do about it.
The conservative, rightwing establishment wants a return to the way things were “back in the day”. They say children need authoritative parents who can dispense discipline and choose a path for them. The liberal, leftwing establishment sees our children’s salvation in staying out of the way, letting them “find their own place” in the world, and above all never disciplining. Both sides can make sense, depending on how militant the spokesman is, but neither sees the whole picture. I don’t pretend to know the answer, but I know neither side is wholly right or wrong.
I do believe that the experts and psychologists are right about one thing: today’s kids are indeed bored. Bored enough with life that taking drugs, getting stoned and having sex with a near-stranger isn’t strange to them. It’s just a way to pass the summer. Director Larry Clark wants the world to see this behaviour. He wants parents, oblivious to the sex, drugs and delinquency of their children, to wake up. His first film, Kids, featured some startling material and never flinched from showing the dirty stuff. His Kids were cold, lifeless and mostly ignorant of the consequences of their actions. It was a stunning picture, and promised great things to come.
Come they have in the form of Bully, Clark’s follow-up picture. So what, I wondered, would Clark take on this time? What would he open my eyes to today? Unfortunately, the subject is. . . the way today’s kids are bored, uninspired and experimenting in startling behaviour. Clark has essentially remade Kids, with a dash of The River’s Edge thrown in.
Bully features another group of aimless teenagers. Some obviously look like “troublemakers”; there’s Heather (Kelli Garner) with the green streaks in her hair and fresh out of rehab, Donny (Michael Pitt), the poster boy for Perpetually Stoned Magazine, and Ali (Bijou Phillips), who opens the film wearing a shirt so short the bottoms of her breasts are showing. But most look like clean-cut, “normal” kids; Lisa (Rachel Minor) looks like the girl next door and Marty and Bobby (Brad Renfro and Nick Stahl) are good-looking surfers.
The group spends all day trying different sexual partners, dropping acid, and staring into space. When they realize that Bobby treats Marty like dirt, the group decides to kill Marty. At first it is a joke, but one by one they slowly warm to the idea, until the night comes to actually do the deed. I won’t say whether they go through with the act or not, but it largely does not matter. What matters is that these teenagers contemplate killing one of their own for being a bully, with no emotion whatsoever. The River’s Edge dealt with similar issues years ago, but there is a vast difference between the two films.
River’s Edge was able to get its message across with dialogue and strong performances. Larry Clark needs to use exploitation. Bully is literally filled to bursting with sex. In the first ten scenes, at least 7 feature a naked teenager, and the count hits at least 18 by the film’s end. At first, there is a point being made; namely that these teenagers are having unprotected sex with multiple partners, getting pregnant and shrugging it off, and simply not thinking about their actions. But after the third or fourth consecutive shot of Ali “going down” on a guy, or Lisa trying out different guys, the point is lost. Bully becomes an ode to pornography, with Clark finding numerous excuses, anything, to get a nipple into each scene. There’s a shot of a naked girl peeing and then walking out of the room. What does it prove? That Rachel Minor is willing to let America see her private parts.
I don’t want to come off as a prude. Nudity has an important role in cinema, especially in a film like Bully. But so much time is spent coupling the characters that we are roughly halfway through the film before the “maybe we could Bobby” story even starts. Clark’s cast is capable enough in their roles that we’re with him much sooner than that. Maybe he didn’t trust that we would get it?
Some time is spent showing parents nodding complacently as they watch their children leave to go party. They ask textbook questions “You kids goin’ out tonight? Okay, don’t be too late. . .” That kind of thing. The suggestion that parents are out of touch with the actions of their children may well be on the money, but the film offers nothing else as being to blame, which I find a bit much. Blaming parents is a cop-out, it is too easy.
Much of what made Kids so strong a picture returns in Bully. Clark’s direction is a bit more controlled and slick this time, and once again there is a great soundtrack backing things up. There is an occasional laugh, most coming from Donny the stoner, and several moments in the film are powerful, especially when it is time to decide whether everyone is serious or not about the plan to murder Bobby. Also powerful is the film’s treatment of the characters’ emotions, or lack of them. This was Clark’s forte in Kids, and he has not lost his touch.
Ultimately, I think our kids will be okay. I think North America has been in a satisfied funk for years, enjoying the fruits of democracy and losing sight of the hardened children of other countries, who are capable of killing without a thought by age ten. But the horrific events of the very recent past will go a long way to opening the eyes of our youth. The difficulties of life are about to be forced into their faces, and maybe now they will realize that life is about more than smoking weed and getting drunk every night.
I believe that kids today have simply had no reason to worry about life, because democracy provides everything they need at cheap prices. Maybe now they can learn to appreciate what they have and put it to good use. They will never stop drinking or smoking, nor should they, but they will recognize these actions as the diversions they are, not a way of life. At least, we can hope they will. It is just too bad that such a catastrophe was needed to accomplish such a needed feat.
Grade: C-
Tim Chandler
